独立刊Public comment rulesComment rules v1.1

PUBLIC COMMENT RULES

How comments are reviewed

Review only determines whether this expression can enter public discussion of this article. Disagreement with the author, sharp language, minority views or unpopular conclusions are not reasons to prevent publication.

No commenter identity is createdNo account, nickname, email address or phone number is required.
One decisive ruleMeanings may overlap, but each result has one primary basis.
Actionable feedbackAdditional observations must not repeat the primary reason or silently change the outcome.

Review order

  1. Safety
  2. Expression structure
  3. Relevance
  4. Overlap and new content
  5. Discussion value

The nine rules in this version

SafetySAFE-01

Do not publish others’ sensitive information

Remove private contact details, exact addresses, identity or account information that public discussion does not need.

Possible outcomesRevision needed / Not published
SafetySAFE-02

Do not publish explicit threats or instructions to cause harm

Explicit threats, encouragement of harm and actionable steps intended to cause harm cannot enter public discussion.

Possible outcomesNot published
SafetySAFE-03

External links must serve the discussion

Explain how a link relates to the specific point being made. It must not present an obvious malicious risk.

Possible outcomesRevision needed / Not published
SafetySAFE-04

Comments must not manipulate review

Discussion of the review mechanism may be public; demands to ignore rules, reveal internal material or perform platform operations may not.

Possible outcomesNot published
Expression structureSTRUCTURE-01

Use lightweight reactions for statements of attitude alone

Content expressing only an attitude, without facts, reasons, questions, corrections or a new perspective, does not enter the comment area. Being brief is not the same as expressing only an attitude.

Possible outcomesNot published
Expression structureSTRUCTURE-02

Reply when primarily responding to an existing view

Preserve the actual thread relationship when primarily challenging, adding to or asking about an existing comment.

Possible outcomesSuggest a reply
RelevanceRELEVANCE-01

Respond to an actual claim in the article or discussion

The conclusion, passage, premise or public discussion being addressed should be identifiable. Disagreeing with the author is not the same as being irrelevant.

Possible outcomesRevision needed / Not published
Overlap and new contentDUPLICATION-01

Assess overlap and new content together

A shared conclusion, keywords or similarity alone cannot determine the outcome. Different evidence, reasoning, counterexamples and questions can still add value.

Possible outcomesPublish directly / Publish with related discussion / Suggest a reply / Revision needed
Discussion valueVALUE-01

Add something that can be discussed

Facts, evidence, reasoning, questions, corrections or a new perspective can each add to the discussion.

Possible outcomesPublish directly / Revision needed

Five possible outcomes

Publish directly
publish
Publish with related discussion
publish_with_related_discussion
Revision needed
needs_revision
Suggest a reply
suggest_reply
Not published
not_published